70 years ago: Hong Kong's wartime diaries
29 Oct 1943, Chronology of Events Related to Stanley Civilian Internment Camp
Submitted by brian edgar on Mon, 2012-04-09 19:17Book / Document:Date(s) of events described:Fri, 29 Oct 1943Thirty three people are executed on Stanley Beach soon after 2 p.m. All have been involved in one way or another with resistance activities organised by the British Army Aid Group.
The Stanley internees among that number are:
The condemned are taken out of solitary confinement and assembled inside Stanley Prison. They are refused a visit from a priest, but are allowed five minutes together to compose themselves Captain Mateen Ansari gives an impromptu talk:
We will die strong and healthy for an ideal; not as traitors but nobly in our country's cause.
Wong Shiu Pun, who had worked at St. Paul's College, leads prayers. Then it's time to go.
As well as the six men arrested in Stanley, there is at least one other whose fate is of deep personal concern: the wife (Florence) and son (Michael) of Charles Hyde are living in Bungalow D. And Thomas Monaghan, who sent in relief to Irish policemen and smuggled in medicines for Tweed Bay Hospital, is also in the execution party.
Former Camp Quartermaster W. J. Anderson has heard the rumours about impending execution that swept the prison in the morning and has managed to get himself on gardening duty so as to witness the condemned starting on their final journey.
The van sets off on the short drive to Stanley Beach soon after 2 pm.
Chester Bennett was briefly interned in Stanley before being released to buy extra food for the Camp. War reporter Hal Boyle tells the story from Bennett's perspective, starting with the American's last moments in his cell:
He gave the note ((a final message to his wife)) to a friendly guard and soon it was time to go. The crowded black van pulled out from the steel gates of Stanley Prison and moved slowly down the rough, narrow road leading to the small bay where British redcoats had planted the empire flag more than a hundred years before.
As the van passed a number of internees toiling up the slope someone put his face up to the rear wire grill and called out: "Goodbye boys. We shan't be seeing you again." ((Believed to be Scott or Fraser.))
At the bottom of the hill the prisoners were forced to dismount and follow a trail winding around the edge of the bay. It must have been torture at every step to Chester Bennett. Rope burns on his left leg had become badly infected, the leg had become gangrenous and needed amputation. But he walked upright and limped only slightly. To all outward appearances he was utterly calm. The prisoners marched in single file to a small clearing. Ringing the hills around them were scores of Chinese gravestones. Before them in the center of the clearing the prisoners saw two trenches dug by Indian warders and knew how they were to die.
The beheadings begin, but the executioner tires and the swords lose their sharpness: some of the victims have to be finished off with bullets - Anderson hears these shots from the prison garden, as do some internees, leading to the idea that the prisoners have all been executed by firing squad.
Anne Ozorio describes the unflinching demeanour of Wong Shiu Pun, who does his best to pray with and comfort the victims, as these dreadful events play themselves out:
By the time it came to him the swords were blunt. But he kept praying.
There were 33 victims in total: seventeen Chinese, eight British, four Indians, one Canadian, one American, one Portuguese, one Eurasian. 32 were male; Lau Tak Oi, the wife of resistance leader David Loie, was the only woman.
Rumours fly around the Camp, but official confirmation of the deaths is not given until November 2.
Dorothy Jenner is lying in her cot; she believes she sees Walter Scott appear in the doorway and say, 'I'll see you again'. A quarter of an hour later a friend tells her that Scott has been executed and gives her, at Scott's request, a small parcel containing his police uniform, badge and arm-tags.
Sources:
Ansari's talk, Wong Shiu Pun: George Wright-Nooth, Prisoner of the Turnip Heads, 1994, 186.
Anderson: rumours and garden: Deposition, page 24, points 211-213, shots: 215; some of Wright-Nooth's account is based on points 212-215 of this (HK Public Records Office 163-1-104) and Hal Boyle's account (below) are the most reliable near contemporary sources for the executions;
Hal Boyle: https://brianedgar.wordpress.com/2011/11/16/part-4-of-hal-boyles-series-...(Boyle's source was Bennett's friend and fellow BAAG agent Marcus da Silva, who made it his business to find out what happened; Anderson and da Silva give substantially the same description and I believe all other accounts to be inaccurate. Some details are different though, and there are, for example, a number of possible versions of the exact wording and circumstances of the farewell message from the van).
Anne Ozorio: https://www.facebook.com/groups/308617469269780/
33 victims: this is the best estimate of nationalities and ethnicities I have been able to arrive at so far. I suspect that it underestimates the number of Eurasians who gave their lives; for a list of names see http://brianedgar.wordpress.com/2013/07/17/the-executions-of-october-29-1943-update/
Jenner: Dorothy Jenner and Trish Sheppard, Darlings, I've Had A Ball, 1975, 214
Note:
I'm gradually writing posts on my blog about all of the 33 victims. For some of the people mentioned here see:
http://brianedgar.wordpress.com/2012/03/31/alexander-christie-sinton/
http://brianedgar.wordpress.com/2012/08/07/thomas-christopher-monaghans-resistance-work/
http://brianedgar.wordpress.com/2012/04/20/charles-hydes-resistance-work/
http://brianedgar.wordpress.com/2011/11/16/chester-bennett-the-american-hero-of-hong-kong/
http://brianedgar.wordpress.com/2013/10/14/lau-tak-oi-gladys-loie/
29 Oct 1943, R. E. Jones Wartime diary
Submitted by Admin on Sat, 2013-10-05 14:59Book / Document:Date(s) of events described:Fri, 29 Oct 1943Dry, cloudy, cooler.
Executions down by pier.
Choir practice 6-7.30 in a field W of Prison.
Canteen buyer.
List of people executed on 29th October, 1943
Submitted by David on Sat, 2015-05-16 14:26Book / Document:Date(s) of events described:Fri, 29 Oct 1943The following list shows the people who have a page on Gwulo, and who died on 29th October, 1943. This was the day that the Japanese executed over 30 people on the beach at Stanley.
Brian has more details about these people and the day's events at:
http://gwulo.com/node/11380Alias / nickname Given Family 
Maiden DoB DoD Sex Mateen Ahmed Ansari 1915 1943 Male Ahmed Basher 1943 Male The American Hero of Hong Kong Chester Bennett 1892 1943 Male Frederick William Bradley 1893 1943 Male 陳炳勳 Ping-fun Chan 1943 Male Cleveland Elroy John Changyit 1943 Male Yung Sam Cheung 1943 Male John Alexander Fraser 1896 1943 Male Frederick Ivan George Hall 1916 1943 Male Ginger Charles Frederick Hyde 1900 1943 Male BAAG No. 60.i George Kotwall 1943 Male 劉德愛 Tak Oi Lau 1943 Female 劉德光 Tak Kwong Lau 1905 1943 Male Hung Hoi Lee 1943 Male Hung Leung / Leong 1912 1943 Male Ching-kit Luk 1925 1943 Male Thomas Christopher Monaghan 1890 1943 Male Hubert Stanley Rees 1900 1943 Male Walter Richardson Scott 1899 1943 Male Alexander Christie Sinton 1897 1943 Male Douglas William Waterton 1901 1943 Male William John White 1883 1943 Male BAAG codename PREST / PRESS Preston Wong 1890 1943 Male BAAG No. 71.ii / James Kim Cheuk-ming Yan 1943 Male BAAG No. 105 (?) / 楊守德 Sau-tak Yeung 1943 Male 29 Oct 1943, Eric MacNider's wartime diary
Submitted by Old Man on Sat, 2015-06-06 22:52Book / Document:Date(s) of events described:Fri, 29 Oct 1943No concert (Executed)
29 Oct 1943, Report from the New Zealand Internees Association
Submitted by David on Thu, 2016-03-10 14:12Book / Document:Date(s) of events described:Fri, 29 Oct 1943((On board the Gripsholm, nursing sister May Waters writes out the following report from the New Zealand Internees Association she'd been given to memorise before leaving Stanley. She attaches a covering letter and sends them both to Mr Thomson, father of one of the internees.))
M.S. Gripsholm
29.10.43Dear Mr. Thomson,
Better introduce myself first, one of the Canadian sisters that was at Bowen Rd and Stanley Internment Camp with your daughter Kathleen.
The enclosed report is from the New Zealanders in Camp and your son, Peter, asked me if I would send it to you and ask you to send it to the New Zealand Government and to use your own judgment showing it to anyone else.
I only received it 4 days before leaving camp and had to memorise it during a very busy time. I know I haven't the exact words in two or three places but quite sure I have conveyed the same meaning.
Kae Christie ((sic.)) the other Canadian sister was going to write Mrs. Thomson but as she has a great many letters to write perhaps this one can do two duties.
Kathleen and Peter are thin but both fairly well. Everyone is lacking in energy but I must say your two keep themselves fairly busy. Believe Peter is teaching as well as the other duties there are to do, depending what squad you are in, rations, wood cutting etc. Kathleen always seems to be busy too. If not studying she's looking after someone's child. ’’Aunty Kate” is quite a favorite.
Kathleen has received several letters from home but can't understand why you don’t tell her the names of the new nieces and nephews. Since June mail has been gradually trickling through. Very little before that and some still not getting any.
Kae and I consider ourselves extremely lucky to be on our way home and we do hope the others will get out next month. Altho' we are on the Gripsholm we still receive very little news.
I do hope all the Red Cross boxes we saw being loaded on the Teia Maru are safely delivered in Hong Kong before long. Food and medical supplies are needed badly. Kathleen does’nt expect to get home directly they are repatriated but thinks she will have to go wherever the S.A’s are sent. ?? ((right edge of page damaged, and some text not clear)) course one can never tell. Perhaps we may meet in England. Just at l??? keep in touch.
Hope you receive a letter from both Kathleen and Peter. Letter?? were supposed to of come out at the same time. Don’t worry about them, ?? sure Kathleen will be out soon and there should be food for the men.
This is a very disjointed letter but it is rather dfficult to know just what to tell you. You can really get it all from the N.Z. report. It was a great pleasure knowing and working with your daughter. She did ?? wonderful job. Both send their love to all the family.
Sincerely yours,
May Watus. ((sic.))
NEW ZEALAND.
This report is sent by the New Zealand Internees Association to supplement the private and general report of the Camp to the British Government.
We suggest that if you have not a copy of the latter report, you obtain one as soon as possible.
STATUS OF N.Z.I.A.
This Association was formed by the unanimous vote of all New Zealanders interned in Stanley.
Present officials are:- L. Thomson (Chairman) ((Possibly L O Thompson?)); R.Wild (Secretary); T. Williamson (Hon.Government Representative). ((Not sure who this was.))
There is another organisation known as the Australian and New Zealand Society but it is not representative of New Zealanders in Hong Kong or in Camp.
PERSONNEL.
The New Zealanders in Stanley now number 16 males 8 females (all adults). 4 adults and 2 children returned to Shanghai last year. There have been no deaths among New Zealanders in Stanley.
REPORT ON HEALTH AND NUTRITION OF NEW ZEALANDERS IN STANLEY INTERNMENT CAMP, HONG KONG.
A report on Health and nutrition of New Zealanders in Stanley Internment Camp, Hong Kong, as it reflects on the condition of rations of the whole Camp, requires a general introductory paragraph.
Their total caloric value has been as low as 1385 calorus per head per day with 44 grammes of protein, and never higher than 2000 calorus with 60 grammes of protein. This level was reached the 3rd quarter of 1942 and was followed by a steady fall to the present level of 1564 calorus with 44 grammes of "polished" rice and much of the other foods supplied (such as water-buffalo beef, Pacific conger-eel, Chinese "water-spinach") are of a kind not ordinarily regarded fit for human consumption.
I have examined 20 New Zealanders, all but 4 of the total number interned. According to their state of health and nutrition and with the observation that none may be classed as good, I group them as follows:-
9 persons fairly good 5 persons fair 2 persons poor 4 persons very poor. 16 persons have lost an average of 20.2% of their known pre-war weight and a majority continue to lose, 2 only (both women) have gained a little and concerning the remaining two the facts were not available.
12 persons have required treatment for specific nutritional diseases. 5 of these for more than one "malnutrition" deficiency. 9 required Thiamen Treatment for beri beri and allied conditions; 5 required Nicotinic Acid treatment for early signs of pallagra; 1 required treatment for central blindness (Reboflavin deficiency) newly observed in Stanley; 2 required treatment for non-specific malnutrition status.
I have compared these "weight" and "malnutrition" figures with those from a recent general Camp survey and find they correspond closely, so that the findings of the small New Zealand unit are roughly representative of the state of nutrition of the whole camp.
One may fairly conclude that the rations provided to the Internees by the authorities are insufficient and unsuitable to maintain health and prevent the occurrence of potentially fatal nutritional diseases. That these have been prevented and successfully treated is due entirely to the supplementary food and vitamin factors supplied by the Red Cross authorities. Failing these our mortality and morbidity rate must have been overwhelming.
Of general diseases - There have been 5 cases of dysentery, one case of typhus, 1 of erysipelas and 5 cases of moderately serious septic conditions.
(Sgd.) John Allistair Loan. M.B., S.S'c.
17.9.43GENERAL.
The chief anxiety is that the situation regarding food and medical supplies (especially deficiency prophylactics) may become even more critical as the blockade increases.
Therefore, failing repatriation, either under a separate scheme or in conjunction with other British Nationals, we urgently request your co-operation with, or promotion of any scheme to ensure regular relief supplies.
Financial relief, although a help, is not a solution owing to lack of supplies, exorbitant prices and restrictions on purchases by internees.
Allowances irregular, maximum M. Y. 25 buys precisely 3.12 oz tins of canned mutton.
Geographical position of Hong Kong is a big hurdle regarding provisions.
(Sgd.) L. Thomson
Chairman
New Zealand Internees Association
Stanley, Hong Kong.
((Transcribed from the copies held at the UK National Archive, their ref: CO 980/120.))
